My son requested a red velvet cake for his birthday and I decided to order this one since it made Oprah's list. The cake is moist and the cream cheese frosting is rich and delicious. I just ordered another to send to my mom. This was my first red velvet cake so I have nothing to compare it to, but my family really enjoyed it! Take the plastic wrap off before the cake thaws out. I forgot to do this- the frosting gets really soft at room temperature and it makes it tricky to unwrap it. Not a big deal, I just smoothed it with a butter knife.